Licensed Florida Real Estate BrokerageIntegrated Closing ServicesMLS AccessBuy With or Without an Agent
33957 Real Estate Market
Real numbers from your local market. Explained for regular people.
As of September 27, 2026
331
Homes For Sale
Active inventory buyers can choose from
23
New In The Last 30 Days
Listings newly added to the market
20
Price Changes In The Last 30 Days
Homes that changed price this week
12
Went Under Contract
Homes that found a buyer this week
2
Back On Market
Homes returned for sale this week
641 Periwinkle Unit A-3
Sanibel, FL 33957
1 bd · 1 ba · 638 sq ft
Condo
Waterfront · $469 per sq ft · HOA about $750 per month
1919 Olde Middle Gulf Unit 102
Sanibel, FL 33957
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,005 sq ft
Condo
Waterfront · $845 per sq ft · HOA about $1,350 per month
824 Birdie View
Sanibel, FL 33957
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,363 sq ft
Single Family
$561 per sq ft · HOA about $4 per month
5885 Pine Tree
Sanibel, FL 33957
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,812 sq ft
Single Family
Waterfront · $626 per sq ft · No HOA
1272 Par View
Sanibel, FL 33957
4 bd · 4 ba · 2,581 sq ft
Single Family
$812 per sq ft · HOA about $4 per month
845 Gulf Unit 632
Sanibel, FL 33957
2 bd · 2 ba · 981 sq ft
Condo
$560 per sq ft · HOA about $1,386 per month
4452 Gulf Pines
Sanibel, FL 33957
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,084 sq ft
Single Family
$444 per sq ft · HOA about $152 per month
9421 Moonlight
Sanibel, FL 33957
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,453 sq ft
Single Family
Waterfront · $446 per sq ft · HOA about $23 per month
Buyers Have More Negotiating Power
14.6 months
Months Of Homes For Sale
If no new homes came up for sale, it would take about 14.6 months to sell the homes currently available.
Real estate term: Months of Supply
$1,012,500
Typical Sale Price
$535
Typical Price Per Sq. Ft.
92.7%
Of Asking Price
At this ZIP's typical close-to-list ratio, a home listed at $500,000 would have sold for about $464,000.
251 days
Typical Time To Sell
15.4%
Share Of Homes Listed Before
Some homes are relisted, which restarts the clock on most sites. This counts total time on market.
As of September 27, 2026
43.8%
Of Homes For Sale Are Below Their Original Asking Price
6
Price Changes This Week
20
Price Changes In The Last 30 Days
1.8%
Share Of Inventory That Changed Price This Week
$90,000 (9.2%)
Typical Reduction Among Reduced Listings
More sellers changing their asking price can be a sign that buyers are being selective.
Buyers Have More Negotiating Power
8.5 months
Months Of Homes For Sale
If no new homes came up for sale, it would take about 8.5 months to sell the homes currently available.
Real estate term: Months of Supply
$1,107,500
Typical Sale Price
$496
Typical Price Per Sq. Ft.
91.7%
Of Asking Price
At this ZIP's typical close-to-list ratio, a home listed at $500,000 would have sold for about $459,000.
251 days
Typical Time To Sell
17.3%
Share Of Homes Listed Before
Some homes are relisted, which restarts the clock on most sites. This counts total time on market.
As of September 27, 2026
43.3%
Of Homes For Sale Are Below Their Original Asking Price
3
Price Changes This Week
10
Price Changes In The Last 30 Days
2.4%
Share Of Inventory That Changed Price This Week
$120,000 (8.7%)
Typical Reduction Among Reduced Listings
More sellers changing their asking price can be a sign that buyers are being selective.
As of September 27, 2026
$939.5K -> $1.1M Up 15.0% over the last 12 months
The typical sale price moved from $939,500 in Sep 2025 to $1,080,000 in Aug 2026, up $140,500.
Buyers Have More Negotiating Power
16.7 months
Months Of Homes For Sale
If no new homes came up for sale, it would take about 16.7 months to sell the homes currently available.
Real estate term: Months of Supply
13.7%
Share Of Homes Listed Before
As of September 27, 2026
48.7%
Of Homes For Sale Are Below Their Original Asking Price
2
Price Changes This Week
7
Price Changes In The Last 30 Days
1.7%
Share Of Inventory That Changed Price This Week
$74,500 (9.9%)
Typical Reduction Among Reduced Listings
More sellers changing their asking price can be a sign that buyers are being selective.
As of September 27, 2026
$800K -> $817K Up 2.1% over the last 12 months
The typical sale price moved from $800,000 in Sep 2025 to $817,000 in Aug 2026, up $17,000.
There were not enough recent sales to judge the balance of this market.
12.5%
Share Of Homes Listed Before
As of September 27, 2026
75.0%
Of Homes For Sale Are Below Their Original Asking Price
0
Price Changes This Week
0
Price Changes In The Last 30 Days
0.0%
Share Of Inventory That Changed Price This Week
$43,000 (6.5%)
Typical Reduction Among Reduced Listings
More sellers changing their asking price can be a sign that buyers are being selective.
As of September 27, 2026
$1.5M -> $655K Down 54.8% over the last 12 months
The typical sale price moved from $1,450,000 in Oct 2025 to $655,000 in Aug 2026, down $795,000.
There were not enough recent sales to judge the balance of this market.
12.5%
Share Of Homes Listed Before
As of September 27, 2026
25.0%
Of Homes For Sale Are Below Their Original Asking Price
0
Price Changes This Week
1
Price Changes In The Last 30 Days
0.0%
Share Of Inventory That Changed Price This Week
$96,950 (9.7%)
Typical Reduction Among Reduced Listings
More sellers changing their asking price can be a sign that buyers are being selective.
As of September 27, 2026
$529K -> $695K Up 31.4% over the last 12 months
The typical sale price moved from $529,000 in Jan 2026 to $695,000 in Jun 2026, up $166,000.
As of September 27, 2026
| Metric | 33957 Now | Last Year | Sanibel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homes For Sale | 331 | 198 | 331 |
| Typical Sale Price | $1,012,500 33957 matches the city median | $912,985 | $1,012,500 |
| Homes Sold, 30 Days | 20 | 16 | 20 |
As of September 27, 2026, homes in 33957 had 14.6 months of supply, compared with 14.6 months across Sanibel as a whole. The typical home here took 251 days to sell, against 251 days citywide.
Not every home is the same, so if more large or expensive homes sell in a given month, the typical sale price can rise even when the market has not really changed.
1,639 sq ft
Typical Size Of Homes Sold
0.0%
New Construction
Mix By Property Type
The market statistics above describe all of ZIP code 33957. Enter your property address in Sanibel, FL for a property-specific estimate based on your home, not the blended ZIP averages.
Property Address
We use Google Places to find and verify your property.
Address suggestions are still loading. You can keep typing.
Select a property address and choose what brings you here to continue.
No, 33957 currently favors buyers more than sellers right now. As of September 27, 2026, 33957 shows 14.6 months of supply and 331 active listings, conditions typical of a buyer's market in Sanibel. Individual results still depend on pricing, condition, and location within the ZIP code.
The typical home in 33957 took 251 days to sell as of September 27, 2026, counting total time on market including any earlier listing periods for the same property. That figure reflects recent closed sales in Sanibel, not just the homes currently listed for sale in the ZIP code today.
Homes in 33957 sold for about 92.7% of asking price as of September 27, 2026, based on the median close-to-list ratio over the last 30 days, meaning a home listed at $500,000 typically sold for about $464,000. That figure includes homes that sold above list and below list within ZIP code 33957.
33957 is currently a buyer's market as of September 27, 2026, with about 14.6 months of supply and 331 homes currently for sale. Months of supply compares active inventory to recent sales, and values below about 4 months generally favor sellers while values above about 6 months favor buyers in Sanibel.
Home prices in 33957 were up 10.9% year over year as of September 27, 2026, comparing the median sale price from the last 90 days with the same period a year earlier. Monthly swings can differ, but that figure shows the broader price direction for closed sales in ZIP code 33957.
As of September 27, 2026, there are 331 homes for sale in ZIP code 33957, representing active MLS listings buyers can shop today. That count shifts weekly as new listings arrive and others go under contract, so check back for the latest inventory in the ZIP code.
Selling a home in 33957 through HomeJam starts at $499 for the DIY tier, with Guided at 1 percent and Concierge at 2.5 percent of the sale price. Your total cost depends on which tier you choose plus other transaction expenses such as title, taxes and any concessions you agree to.
Market statistics are calculated using MLS data for ZIP code 33957.
Data is updated weekly. Last updated September 27, 2026.
Based on information from the Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service, Inc. for the period September 1, 2025 through September 27, 2026.
We use cookies and similar tools to remember how you found us, keep a session identifier, and understand which property pages you view. You can accept this use or decline optional tracking. See our privacy notice.
